What to look for when shopping for renters insurance

If you rent a house or apartment and experience a fire or other disaster, your landlord’s insurance will only cover the costs of repairing the building. To financially protect yourself you will need to buy renters or tenants insurance.

Renters Insurance Protections

Like homeowners insurance, renters insurance includes three key types of financial protection:

  • Coverage for personal possessions
  • Liability protection
  • Additional living expenses (ALE)

The big difference is that renters insurance doesn’t cover the building or structure of the apartment—that’s the landlord’s responsibility.

The following questions will help you choose the right coverage when you are shopping around for renters insurance or discussing your needs with an insurance professional.

Coverage for Personal possessions

Coverage for your personal property is a key component of renters coverage, protecting you from theft, fire and a host of other unfortunate events.

1. How much insurance should I buy?

Make sure you have enough insurance to replace all of your personal possessions in the event of a burglary, fire, or other covered disaster. The easiest way to determine the value of all your personal possessions is to create a home inventory—a detailed list of all of your belongings along with their estimated value.

2. Should I choose replacement cost or actual cash value coverage?

Actual cash value policies include a deduction for depreciation (that is, the idea that items lose value over time). Replacement cost coverage is pricier but can be well worth the extra expense if your belongings are damaged or destroyed (think about how much you’d get for your TV used versus how much it would actually cost to replace).

3. What disasters are—and are not—covered?

Renters insurance covers you against losses from fire or smoke, lightning, vandalism, theft, explosion, windstorm and certain types of water damage (such as from a burst pipe or when the tenant upstairs leaves the water running in the bathtub and floods your apartment).

Like standard homeowners policies, most renters insurance policies do not cover floods or earthquakes. Flood coverage is available from the National Flood Insurance Program and a few private insurers. You can get earthquake insurance as a separate policy or have it added as an endorsement to your renters policy, depending on where you live.

4. What is my deductible, and how does it work?

A deductible is an amount of money you are responsible for paying before your insurance coverage. For example, if you have a $500 deductible and a fire destroys $5000 worth of furniture, the first $500 is your responsibility, and your insurance company will cover $4500.

Renters insurance deductibles are generally specified as a dollar amount, which can be found on the Declarations page of your policy. In general, the larger the deductible, the lower your insurance premium.

5. What is a “floater” and do I need one?

A floater is a separate policy that provides additional coverage for more costly valuables if they are lost or stolen. If you have expensive jewelry, furs, collectibles, sports equipment, or musical instruments, consider adding a floater to your policy to protect against their loss.

6. Am I covered if I am traveling or away from home?

Most renters polices include what is called off-premises coverage, which means belongings that are outside of your home are covered against the same disasters listed in your policy. For example, property stolen from your car or a hotel room while you’re traveling would be protected.

Liability Protection

7. What is liability insurance?

Renters insurance provides liability protection that covers you against lawsuits for bodily injury or property damage done by you, your family members, and even your pets. This coverage pays for the cost of defending you in court, up to the limit of your policy.

Your renters policy should also include no-fault medical coverage as part of the liability protection. Medical payments coverage allows someone who gets injured on your property to simply submit his or her medical bills directly to your insurance company so the bills can be paid without resorting to a lawsuit.

8. Do I have enough liability insurance?

Make sure the amount of liability coverage provided by your policy is sufficient to protect your financial and other material assets in the event of a lawsuit.

9. Do I need an umbrella liability policy?

If you need a larger amount of liability protection, consider purchasing a personal umbrella liability policy. An umbrella policy kicks in when you reach the limit on the underlying liability coverage provided by your renters or auto policy. It will also cover you for things such as libel and slander.

Additional Living Expenses

Additional living expenses (ALE) coverage provides coverage if your home is destroyed by an insured disaster and you need to live elsewhere for a time.

10. What does ALE cover?

The additional living expenses portion of your rental insurance policy pays for hotel bills, temporary rentals, restaurant meals and other expenses you incur while your rental home is being repaired or rebuilt. Essentially, it covers the expenses you would not have to incur if you had your usual roof over your head.

11. How much does ALE cover?

Most policies will reimburse you the full difference between your additional living expenses and your normal living expenses; however, there are generally limits as to the total amount the insurer will pay or time limits specifying how long you’re eligible for the ALE payments. Make sure you’re comfortable with the limits of the policy you choose

Multiple Policy and Other Discounts

12. What types of discounts are offered on renters insurance?

Insurance companies often offer discounts on renters insurance if you have another policy with them—for example, car insurance or business insurance.

You may also get a discount if you:

  • Have a security system
  • Use smoke detectors
  • Use deadbolt locks
  • Have good credit
  • Stay with the same insurer
  • Are over 55 years old

Discounts may vary widely by insurance company and by state, so review your options carefully.

Source: Insurance Information Institute

Read Other Blog Posts

Extension Cord 1200

Stay Wired Into Electrical Safety This May

May is National Electric Safety Month. While electricity is an integral part of our daily lives and powers many essential appliances and devices, electrocution and other related risks should be taken seriously. Even a slight mishap or oversight could lead to serious injuries and damage to your home. Follow these safety tips.
Hurricane Season in New England What Homeowners Need to Know to Stay Protected

Hurricane Season in New England: What Homeowners Need to Know to Stay Protected

Hurricane season impacts New England more than many homeowners expect. From flooding to wind damage, preparation is key. Learn how to review your insurance, protect your property, and stay safe before, during, and after a storm.
Motorcyclist Cord 1200

Stay Safe With Motorcycle Safety Awareness Month

May is Motorcycle Safety Awareness Month. This time is dedicated to helping bikers and their passengers remain safe while cruising the road. Although your bike can be a thrilling and exciting way to travel, it’s also often more dangerous than using a passenger car. Check out safety tips to keep in mind.
Steering wheelSteering wheel

What Should You Do After a Car Accident to Help Your Insurance Claim?

A car accident can be stressful and overwhelming, especially in the moments that follow. This checklist outlines practical steps drivers can take after an accident to protect themselves, document key details, and help keep the insurance claims process on track
Murphy Insurance Proudly Sponsors the Groton Road Race

Murphy Insurance Proudly Sponsors the Groton Road Race

Murphy Insurance Agency is proud to sponsor the 2026 Groton Road Race on May 3. With 5K, 10K, and Fun Run options, this beloved local event brings runners and families together to celebrate community, health, and one of Groton’s best traditions.
Plumbing & Water Damage | Homeowner's Manual Blog Series

Plumbing & Water Damage Prevention | Homeowner’s Manual Blog Series

Water damage is one of the most common and costly issues homeowners face, but many problems are preventable. From fixing leaks to maintaining sump pumps, simple steps can protect your home. Explore practical tips from Murphy Insurance’s Homeowner’s Manual to stay ahead.
Why Flood Insurance Matters

Why Flood Insurance Matters

Flooding can cause costly damage to homes and create health risks from mold, even outside high-risk zones. Because standard homeowners insurance excludes flood damage and losses are rising, flood insurance is a critical layer of protection for homeowners.
Massachusetts Boaters A New Safety Requirement You Need to Know Before Summer

Massachusetts Boaters: A New Safety Requirement You Need to Know Before Summer

Massachusetts boaters should be aware of a new safety law taking effect in 2026. Many operators will now need a boating safety certificate based on age. Learn who is affected, key deadlines, and how to complete an approved course before the season begins.
Why Umbrella Insurance Matters for Local Families in Bolton, MA

Why Umbrella Insurance Matters for Local Families in Bolton, MA

Umbrella insurance provides added liability protection beyond your home and auto policies—essential for Bolton, MA, families with high-value homes, teenage drivers, or those involved in recreational activities. Learn how Murphy Insurance can help you safeguard your future with affordable coverage tailored to your lifestyle.

Visit Our Homeowners Insurance Page

Homeowners Insurance

At Murphy Insurance, we take great care in assessing your options for homeowners insurance to ensure that you receive the most favorable value. Our dedication to serving you entails collaborating with highly-rated insurance providers and conducting comprehensive assessments of available choices. Our goal is to achieve the ideal equilibrium between affordability and coverage that suits your unique needs. Please let us provide you with a customized homeowners insurance quote.