5 Risks of Hiring an Uninsured Contractor

Imagine a subcontractor’s ladder falls and damages a vehicle—or worse, injures someone passing by. Without insurance, that liability lands on you.

These five risks show why hiring uninsured contractors can expose your business to costly legal, financial, and safety consequences.

Legal Violations and Penalties

Hiring uninsured contractors may breach local, state or federal regulations that mandate specific insurance coverage on construction sites. This can result in fines, penalties or even project shutdowns. Verifying insurance coverage helps ensure compliance and protects against costly legal consequences.

Liability for On-the-Job Injuries

If an uninsured contractor or their employee is injured while working, the responsibility for medical bills and lost wages may fall on the project owner or general contractor. In many jurisdictions, workers’ compensation laws extend liability to the hiring entity when the contractor lacks coverage.

Out-of-Pocket Costs for Property Damage

Should an uninsured contractor cause damage to property during the project, the financial burden may shift to the project owner or general contractor. Without general liability insurance in place, there would likely be no safety net to cover the resulting repair or replacement costs.

Exposure to Third-Party Injury Claims

If a worksite visitor, pedestrian or other third party is injured due to the actions of an uninsured contractor, the project owner or general contractor could be held liable. Without the contractor’s liability insurance to cover medical expenses, legal fees or settlements, these costs may come directly out of the hiring party’s pocket.

Increased Safety Risks

Uninsured contractors often lack the motivation and resources to adhere to industry safety standards or invest in proper training and equipment. This can lead to unsafe working conditions, higher accident rates and potential violations of OSHA regulations. Hiring insured contractors helps promote a culture of safety and accountability on the job site.

The Bottom Line

Hiring uninsured contractors poses a wide range of legal, financial and safety risks. Ensuring that all contractors carry adequate insurance is a critical step in protecting personnel, third parties, projects and finances and maintaining high jobsite safety standards.

Contact us today if you have questions about screening subcontractors to protect your business.

Read Our Business Blog Posts

Floorplan 1200

5 Risks of Hiring an Uninsured Contractor

Project owners and general contractors must thoroughly vet all contractors to ensure jobsite safety and protect against financial losses. A key part of this vetting process is confirming that contractors carry the appropriate insurance coverage. Hiring uninsured contractors can lead to serious consequences, including safety risks, legal liabilities and unexpected costs. Here are five major risks of hiring uninsured contractors that highlight why adequate insurance is essential.
Paperwork 1200

Medicare Part D Notices Are Due Before Oct. 15, 2025

Plan sponsors must provide the annual disclosure notice to Medicare-eligible individuals before Oct. 15, 2025—the start date of the annual enrollment period for Medicare Part D. This notice is important because Medicare beneficiaries who are not covered by creditable prescription drug coverage and do not enroll in Medicare Part D when first eligible will likely pay higher premiums if they enroll at a later date.
OSHA Safe & Sound Week

OSHA’s Safe and Sound Week Runs From August 11-17, 2025

More than 5,000 workers are killed on the job each year, and more than 3.6 million employees are seriously injured each year while at work. Because of this, OSHA holds a nationwide event each August called Safe and Sound Week, which promotes the importance of companies incorporating safety and health programs into their workplaces. This year, the event runs August 11-17, 2025.
Hudson Family Dental

Business Spotlight: Hudson Family Dental Providing Modern Dentistry in the Heart of Hudson

Hudson Family Dental has been providing modern, compassionate dentistry in Hudson, MA since 1988. With cutting-edge technology and a team dedicated to personalized care, they’ve earned the trust of local families for generations. Learn how this Main Street practice blends innovation with community values—and why Murphy Insurance is proud to call them a client.
File folders

Employee Benefits SAR Is Due by September 30 for Calendar Year Plans

Many employers that must file Form 5500 on behalf of their employee benefit plans must also provide plan participants with a summary annual report (SAR). The SAR is a summary of the information included in the Form 5500. Employers with plans that operate on a calendar year basis must provide the SAR by Sept. 30
Balance Scale 1200

Supreme Court Upholds ACA’s Preventive Care Mandate

On June 27, 2025, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a key component of the Affordable Care Act’s (ACA) preventive care mandate. Due to the Court’s ruling, the ACA’s preventive care mandate remains in full effect and health plans and issuers are required to continue covering the entire range of recommended preventive care services without cost sharing.
Updated Hazard Communication Standard

Updated Hazard Communication Standard from OSHA

Employers should review OSHA's the final rule on its Hazard Communication Standard (HCS) to determine how the changes affect them. Specifically, paying attention to their compliance dates for required actions which go into affect in 2026 and 2027.
Business Spotlight Rail Trail Flatbread Co.

Business Spotlight: Rail Trail Flatbread Company & New City Microcreamery

Our Business Spotlight shines on Rail Trail Flatbread Co., an upscale pizza place and the owners of New City Microcreamery and Less Than Greater Than speakeasy, a local business helping revitalize downtown Hudson and beyond. From wood-fired flatbreads to liquid nitrogen-crafted ice cream, this creative group has grown into a thriving family of restaurants and bars, each backed by the trusted protection of Murphy Insurance.
Business Spotlight Elbow Grease Marketing

Business Spotlight: Elbow Grease Marketing

We’re excited to launch our Business Spotlight series by featuring Elbow Grease Marketing, a valued partner and fellow Hudson-based business. EGM has played a key role in helping Murphy Insurance strengthen its brand and grow online. In return, EGM trusts Murphy for both business insurance and the personal insurance needs of its employees. Our partnership is a true example of what local collaboration can accomplish.

Visit Our Business Insurance Page

Contractor Insurance

Being a successful contractor takes more than skill on the job site—it requires planning, discipline, and careful risk management. Every day, your business faces challenges that can disrupt operations and impact your bottom line, from worker injuries and equipment breakdowns to property damage, lawsuits, and unforeseen accidents. Even with strong safety protocols in place, things can still go wrong. That’s why the right Contractor Insurance coverage is essential, providing protection through general liability, workers’ compensation, commercial auto, tools and equipment coverage, and more—all tailored to the unique risks contractors face.