If you’ve ever experienced the proverbial “deer in the headlights” situation, you know how sudden it is when a deer darts across the road. And, if you or someone you know has experienced a deer collision, you appreciate the damage deer can cause and are grateful for a near miss. Please be extra careful while driving October through December. The risk for deer collisions is three times greater at this time of year, according to the Highway Loss Data Institute (HLDI) statistics. Increased deer activity during their migration and mating season causes a sharp increase in auto accidents involving deer.

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) estimates that there are more than 1.5 million deer-vehicle collisions each year. On average, there are between 175 and 200 fatalities and over 100,000 injuries every year. These accidents cause over $1 billion in vehicle damage. Fatal crashes are most likely to occur in rural areas and on roads with speed limits greater than 55 MPH.

How hitting a deer impacts your insurance

The comprehensive coverage part of an auto policy typically covers hitting a deer because it’s not an “at fault” accident. Since no fault is assigned, there is usually no impact on your auto insurance rates.

However, it’s important to note that there must be physical contact with the deer for it to be considered a comprehensive loss claim. Suppose you swerve to avoid a deer (or any other type of unexpected road hazard) and hit another object. In that case, the accident will fall under the collision coverage, considered an “at fault” accident, typically resulting in a surcharge that may increase your insurance rates.

Tips to prevent deer accidents

You can take steps to reduce your chances of deer-vehicle accidents.

  • Use extra caution between dusk and dawn – Deer tend to be nocturnal, so you’re more likely to see them between these hours.
  • Stay alert – Being alert may help you spot deer and allow you to react quickly. Watch for deer crossing signs.
  • Use your high beams – When driving at night, use your high beams when possible to illuminate the side of the road and further ahead. Greater visibility will give you more reaction time.
  • Be aware – Watch for deer-crossing signs. If you travel the same routes and notice deer frequently in the same areas, please make a mental note to be careful.
  • Slow down – If you see an animal at the side of the road, slow down as they move unpredictably.
  • Don’t swerve…Brake – Swerving could cause you to lose control or hit another car/object, which is likely more dangerous than hitting the deer. Brake as quickly and safely as you can. Being alert will help you avoid the temptation to swerve to avoid the unexpected.
  • Where there is one, there’s usually more – Deer travel together. If you see one, it’s likely three more. Slow down, and if one crosses the road, assume others may follow.

While you can’t control where deer or other wildlife will show up or how they will behave, being alert, especially during the months when they are more active, can help you avoid accidents—saving you money and saving your life.

Next steps: Had an accident?  Here’s what to do at the scene.

Source: Highway Loss Data Institute

Read Other Blog Posts

October is Cybersecurity Awareness Month Are You Cyber-Smart at Home and at Work

October is Cybersecurity Awareness Month: Are You Cyber-Smart at Home and at Work?

October is Cybersecurity Awareness Month — the perfect reminder to stay vigilant about your digital safety. From phishing scams to hacked home devices, cyber threats can affect anyone. Learn practical tips to protect yourself at home and work, and see how personal cyber insurance can help safeguard your finances and identity.
Candle on table

Candle Safety Considerations

Candles provide a warm ambiance for an intimate dinner, a sparkling decoration for a birthday cake or a nice scent for your home. Ambiance aside, candles can be a fire hazard if they are left unattended or placed where they can start other objects on fire. If you enjoy candles, be sure to follow these tips to use them safely.
Introducing the Murphy Insurance Condominium Owner’s Manual Your Guide to Preventing Costly Condo Repairs & Damages SMM

Introducing the Murphy Insurance Condominium Owner’s Manual: Your Guide to Preventing Costly Condo Repairs & Damages

Murphy Insurance Agency has launched a new Condominium Owner's Manual designed to help you prevent costly home repairs and avoid common insurance claims. Backed by decades of real-world experience, this practical guide provides seasonal tips, safety advice, and a comprehensive maintenance checklist to protect your home—and your wallet—all year round. Download your copy today!
Deer Sign

Road Safety and Wildlife: What Drivers Need to Know

Every year, countless accidents occur because drivers aren't prepared for unexpected encounters with animals on the road. Whether it's a deer darting across a rural highway or a stray dog wandering into city traffic, these moments can be dangerous for both humans and animals. Staying alert and understanding how to respond in these situations can make a critical difference in preventing harm and keeping roads safer for everyone.
Quest for the Best 2025

We Did It Again! 5-Time Gold Winners in Quest for the Best

We’re proud to announce we’ve won Gold in MyFM 101.3’s Quest for the Best – Insurance Category for the 5th year in a row! Thank you to everyone who voted and continues to support us. If you're a client, we’re grateful for your trust. If you’re looking for a second opinion, we’d love the chance to earn your business.
Happy driver

The Benefits of Raising Your Limits

An overwhelming majority of states require individuals to carry insurance in order to operate a vehicle. While meeting these minimum limits may be enough to get you on the road, they may be inadequate if you are involved in a serious accident. For better protection, you may want to consider raising your limits to secure proper protection.
Murphy Insurance Team

27 Reasons to Work with Murphy Insurance Agency

For more than 88 years, Murphy Insurance Agency has been a trusted partner for families, individuals, and businesses across Massachusetts. As a family-owned and independent agency, we prioritize relationships over transactions, offering guidance and support tailored to your needs. With access to more than 25 top-rated carriers, we deliver personalized solutions, competitive options, and peace of mind. Discover 27 reasons why thousands have chosen Murphy Insurance to protect what matters most.
Personal Article Floater

What Is a Personal Article Floater—and Do You Need One?

Many people assume that their home or renters insurance covers all their personal belongings—but it's not always that simple. While these policies do offer significant protection, there are usually limits, especially when it comes to high-value or one-of-a-kind items. If you own something valuable, rare, or that you often take with you, you may want to consider adding a personal article floater to your coverage.
Home Fall Prep for Winter

Fall Into Home Prep: Smart Projects to Help You Avoid Winter Insurance Claims

Fall is the perfect time to tackle home maintenance projects before winter sets in. Use our seasonal checklist to protect your home, prevent costly damage, and keep everything running smoothly—inside and out.

Visit Our Auto Insurance Page

Auto Insurance

At Murphy Insurance, we are here to assist you in obtaining the appropriate auto insurance. Choosing the appropriate auto insurance coverage can be overwhelming. Every insurance company has its unique offerings, making it challenging to compare options effectively. That’s where we shine. We simplify the process by helping you evaluate provider and policy choices, seek out discounts, and optimize your car insurance within your budget constraints. Ultimately, our goal is to provide you with peace of mind, knowing that you and your loved ones are well-protected.