When deciding about your insurance, it can be a balancing act deciding how much coverage to buy. Understandably, budgetary constraints may impact your coverage; however, it often doesn’t cost significantly more to get a higher protection limit or add an endorsement that broadens coverage. Few people will regret spending a little more for the extra coverage when a claim occurs, preventing a sizeable out-of-pocket expenditure.

Avoiding these common insurance mistakes will help ensure you have solid protection.

Underinsuring your home. Failing to insure your home at its replacement value is the biggest mistake a homeowner can make. The cost to rebuild a home is typically more than its market value and can fluctuate over time due to labor and building supply costs. If your home is significantly underinsured, you may need more funds to rebuild.

Not having extended replacement cost coverage. This optional coverage can pay to rebuild your home exactly as it was, even if the cost exceeds the estimated replacement cost of the house. The primary purpose is to protect you against sudden increases in materials or construction costs that can occur after a hurricane or other disaster. Depending on your policy, extended replacement costs can pay up to an additional 100% of your policy’s Dwelling Coverage limit.

Not considering building code change additional costs. Building codes change periodically. If your home is badly damaged, you may be required to rebuild to meet new building codes. A basic homeowner policy typically excludes these extra expenses. However, you can purchase an “ordinance or law endorsement” that pays a specified amount toward these costs.

Ignoring flood and earthquake coverage. Just because you don’t live along a river or in California doesn’t mean that you don’t need to seriously consider these coverages, which are excluded under a standard home policy.

Not buying renters insurance. If you rent (or cohabitate and don’t own the home you live in), a renters policy not only covers your possessions but also provides liability protection. It also covers additional living expenses if a fire or other covered situation requires that you move out temporarily.

Failing to have replacement cost on contents. Whether you rent or own, make sure your possessions are insured at the cost of replacing them with new comparable items. Otherwise, you’d only receive the depreciated value of your possessions, which is probably only a fraction of what it would cost you to replace them. Imagine having to replace everything, and you’ll quickly see why this is essential.

Purchasing only the most essential coverage. When unexpected accidents in life become a reality, having only basic coverage can still leave a significant financial burden on you. Paying for insurance coverage that doesn’t cover your needs isn’t helpful. Talk to your agent at Murphy Insurance about ways to manage your costs while having higher limits in the areas where the most significant risk exists, such as:

  • bodily injury to others
  • damage to others’ property
  • medical coverage
  • personal liability
  • underinsured/uninsured motorist coverage

Read Other Blog Posts

Hurricane Season in New England What Homeowners Need to Know to Stay Protected

Hurricane Season in New England: What Homeowners Need to Know to Stay Protected

Hurricane season impacts New England more than many homeowners expect. From flooding to wind damage, preparation is key. Learn how to review your insurance, protect your property, and stay safe before, during, and after a storm.
Motorcyclist Cord 1200

Stay Safe With Motorcycle Safety Awareness Month

May is Motorcycle Safety Awareness Month. This time is dedicated to helping bikers and their passengers remain safe while cruising the road. Although your bike can be a thrilling and exciting way to travel, it’s also often more dangerous than using a passenger car. Check out safety tips to keep in mind.
Steering wheelSteering wheel

What Should You Do After a Car Accident to Help Your Insurance Claim?

A car accident can be stressful and overwhelming, especially in the moments that follow. This checklist outlines practical steps drivers can take after an accident to protect themselves, document key details, and help keep the insurance claims process on track
Murphy Insurance Proudly Sponsors the Groton Road Race

Murphy Insurance Proudly Sponsors the Groton Road Race

Murphy Insurance Agency is proud to sponsor the 2026 Groton Road Race on May 3. With 5K, 10K, and Fun Run options, this beloved local event brings runners and families together to celebrate community, health, and one of Groton’s best traditions.
Plumbing & Water Damage | Homeowner's Manual Blog Series

Plumbing & Water Damage Prevention | Homeowner’s Manual Blog Series

Water damage is one of the most common and costly issues homeowners face, but many problems are preventable. From fixing leaks to maintaining sump pumps, simple steps can protect your home. Explore practical tips from Murphy Insurance’s Homeowner’s Manual to stay ahead.
Why Flood Insurance Matters

Why Flood Insurance Matters

Flooding can cause costly damage to homes and create health risks from mold, even outside high-risk zones. Because standard homeowners insurance excludes flood damage and losses are rising, flood insurance is a critical layer of protection for homeowners.
Massachusetts Boaters A New Safety Requirement You Need to Know Before Summer

Massachusetts Boaters: A New Safety Requirement You Need to Know Before Summer

Massachusetts boaters should be aware of a new safety law taking effect in 2026. Many operators will now need a boating safety certificate based on age. Learn who is affected, key deadlines, and how to complete an approved course before the season begins.
Why Umbrella Insurance Matters for Local Families in Bolton, MA

Why Umbrella Insurance Matters for Local Families in Bolton, MA

Umbrella insurance provides added liability protection beyond your home and auto policies—essential for Bolton, MA, families with high-value homes, teenage drivers, or those involved in recreational activities. Learn how Murphy Insurance can help you safeguard your future with affordable coverage tailored to your lifestyle.
Driver with phone

Preventing Distracted Driving

According to the National Safety Council, more than 3,000 people die each year as a result of distracted driving crashes. Keep reading to learn what you can do to reduce potential distractions while you drive—keeping both yourself and others safe on the road.

Visit Our Personal Insurance Page

Personal Insurance

Life is an ever-changing journey, and it deserves a thoughtful, comprehensive plan to protect the things and people that matter most. Our dedicated team at Murphy Insurance is here to assist you in creating that plan. With a wide range of product options at our disposal, we ensure that your plan is tailored precisely to your requirements. Our commitment to providing clear, intelligent guidance to help you achieve true peace of mind. Learn more about our personal insurance portfolio.