Bills can pile up in the chaos of day-to-day personal or business life. It’s not uncommon to forget about a bill payment or feel that end-of-the-month crunch with a tight budget to consider deferring payment and incurring a late fee. However, insurance premium payments differ from other bills…there’s more at stake. Late payments can impact your premium costs and insurability.

Late Fees & Other Costs

Although you might be offered a grace period of a few days before your insurance agent issues a cancellation notice, you will most likely be assessed a late payment fee for being past due. In addition, late payments can impact your insurance score, a rating calculated by insurance companies to represent the probability of an insurance claim being filed, and can affect your premiums. Payments must be received by the due date, so please ensure you leave enough time for delivery.

Cancellation

If you fail to pay, an insurance company has the right to cancel your policy and will issue a cancellation notice within a few days of not receiving payment. If payment is not received by the cancellation date, your policy will be canceled, and the company may choose not to reinstate it.

If they allow you to reinstate your canceled policy, they typically will require not only funds for the missed payment but also the next payment, and in some cases, they may require payment of the remaining premium in full. So, if finances were already challenging, causing a late fee, reinstating your policy would be more costly.

If they choose not to reinstate your policy, you’ll have to find a new insurance provider and could have to pay a higher premium for the same coverage or have difficulty finding a company to insure you.

Consequences of Being Considered a High-Risk Client

Missing one or more insurance payments can result in you being considered “high-risk” by insurance carriers. When your policy expires and is due to be renewed, your current insurance company may:

  • increase your premium or
  • decide not to renew your policy, which effectively cancels it, requiring you to find a new insurance provider.

When applying for a policy with a different company, it will ask and verify if you’ve been canceled for nonpayment, and as a result, it may:

  • require one annual payment (not allow you to pay in installments) or
  • charge you a higher premium, or
  • fail to insure you even if you have a spotless claim record.

If you can’t obtain insurance from a preferred “standard” carrier, you may have to buy coverage from a “nonstandard” carrier that accepts higher risk, or you may have to go through a State program referred to as assigned risk. Both these options will almost always result in higher premiums to obtain coverage.

How to Avoid Missing a Payment

With the above in mind, there are many reasons to avoid missed payments, and you can do so with some planning.

Here are some ideas that can help:

  • Automate payments using EFT automatic withdrawals. It prevents you from having to remember to make manual payments. You may save money by eliminating installment fees if you’re paying in installments. Be sure to use an account you use regularly that doesn’t require a particular transfer of funds to cover the payment, which is a leading cause of missed payments.
  • Pay well in advance of your payment due date. Depending on how you are paying, be sure to leave enough time for the payment to be delivered. Postal mail is slower than it used to be, and even online banking can take a few days for payment.
  • Pay in total if you can afford to do so. Installment payments can be helpful with cash flow, but making one payment reduces the chances of missed payments. Paying in full can save you money with a pay-in-full discount, and you also avoid installment fees.

If you’re having difficulty making a payment, please call and speak to your agent to discuss possible options. Don’t wait until your policy is canceled because it will only cause more headaches.

Read Other Blog Posts

Attract Top Talent in Milford with Competitive Employee Benefits

Attract Top Talent in Milford, MA with Competitive Employee Benefits

In today’s competitive job market, offering strong employee benefits is no longer optional—it’s essential. For Milford, MA, businesses, Murphy Insurance provides customized, affordable benefit solutions that help you attract top talent, reduce turnover, and foster long-term growth.
MHM 1

Introducing the Murphy Insurance Homeowner’s Manual: Your Guide to Preventing Costly Home Repairs & Damages

Murphy Insurance Agency has launched a new Homeowner’s Manual designed to help you prevent costly home repairs and avoid common insurance claims. Backed by decades of real-world experience, this practical guide offers seasonal tips, safety advice, and a maintenance checklist to protect your home—and your wallet—all year long. Download your copy today!
Protecting Your Marlborough Home A Local Guide to Homeowners Insurance

Protecting Your Marlborough Home: A Local Guide to Homeowners Insurance

Thinking about homeowners' insurance in Marlborough, MA? Whether you're settling into your first home or reviewing your coverage, Murphy Insurance offers expert guidance and tailored protection designed for New England’s unique risks. Discover what’s included, what to expect, and how our local team can help you protect what matters most.
House with trees

10 Signs a Tree May Fall on Your Property

Trees can be valuable additions to any property; however, each year, fallen trees and branches cause millions of dollars in property damage. It is crucial to proactively recognize signs a tree may be at risk of falling to help prevent dangerous and costly accidents.
Renters Insurance in Medway, MA Protect Yourself Original

Renters Insurance in Medway, MA: Protect Yourself

Renting in Medway, MA offers convenience—but without renters insurance, your belongings may be at risk. While your landlord’s policy covers the building, it doesn’t protect your personal property or shield you from liability. Renters insurance provides affordable coverage for theft, fire, water damage, and personal liability. With options tailored to your needs, local agencies like Murphy Insurance make it easy to get covered.

Spring Clean Your Insurance: A Fresh Start for Your Policies

With Spring often comes spring cleaning. Have you ever thought about giving your insurance policies a little spring cleaning too? Just like your home, your insurance coverage needs attention and regular updates to ensure it’s still a good fit for your current needs.
Business Insurance in Worcester, MA What You Need To Know Original

Business Insurance in Worcester, MA: What You Need To Know

Running a business in Worcester, MA comes with both opportunities and risks. From property damage to cyber threats, having the right business insurance is essential to protect your investment. Murphy Insurance Agency provides customized coverage for local businesses of all sizes and industries. With over 85 years of experience, we offer trusted advice and tailored solutions to help your business thrive.
What to Do When a Hurricane Threatens

Get Ready for Hurricane Season in New England: What You Need to Know

While New England is not typically directly in the hurricane "strike zone" like the Gulf Coast or the Southeast, that doesn’t mean we’re immune to the dangers of hurricanes and tropical storms. With that in mind, it's important to have a plan as hurricane season approaches and be sure you understand your insurance coverage.
Office workers

Massachusetts Enacts Pay Transparency and Pay Data Reporting Law

The new Massachusetts law, the Frances Perkins Workplace Equity Act, requires employers with 100 or more employees to provide pay data reports to the Massachusetts state secretary effective Feb. 1, 2025, and employers with 25 or more employees to disclose the pay range in job postings effective July 31, 2025.

Visit Our Personal Insurance Page

Personal Insurance

Life is an ever-changing journey, and it deserves a thoughtful, comprehensive plan to protect the things and people that matter most. Our dedicated team at Murphy Insurance is here to assist you in creating that plan. With a wide range of product options at our disposal, we ensure that your plan is tailored precisely to your requirements. Our commitment to providing clear, intelligent guidance to help you achieve true peace of mind. Learn more about our personal insurance portfolio.

Visit Our Business Insurance Page

Business Insurance

Murphy Insurance stands as your steadfast partner in safeguarding your business from unforeseen challenges in today’s dynamic business landscape. In an era where comprehensive business insurance is not just a prudent choice but a vital one for ensuring the long-term stability and security of your enterprise, we are here to offer our expertise. Running a business inherently entails various risks that can potentially impact your financial stability and reputation. Learn more about our comprehensive business insurance solutions, which are meticulously designed to protect you from these potential threats, granting you peace of mind necessary to focus on the growth and prosperity of your business.