Insurance companies are quick to deny claims | Insurance Myths

June 2, 2025|Insurance Myths|business insurance, claims, claims process, personal insurance

While it’s true that not every claim gets approved, the idea that insurers are eager to reject claims isn’t accurate. Most insurance providers aim to resolve claims fairly and help policyholders recover after unexpected events. Let’s explore why this myth doesn’t hold up and what you can do to ensure a smooth claims process.

❌Why Claims Are Sometimes Denied

Claims may be denied for several legitimate reasons, including:

  • Policy Exclusions: Some types of damage or events may not be covered under your specific policy. For example, flood damage often requires separate insurance.
  • Incomplete Documentation: Missing or incorrect information can delay or derail the claims process.
  • Uninsured Events: If the event causing the loss isn’t covered by your policy, the claim may be denied.
  • Policy Lapses: Failing to keep your policy active by paying premiums can result in denied claims.

While denials can happen, they’re not arbitrary. Insurance companies follow strict guidelines and regulations to ensure fairness.

Check marks
Click here to submit an inquiry to Murphy Insurance or call us at 800 222 8711

🔎The Truth About Claims Handling

As a rule, insurance companies strive to provide excellent customer service and resolve claims promptly. Their goal is to build trust and retain customers by:

  • Evaluating Claims Thoroughly: Insurers investigate claims to ensure they’re valid and covered under the policy.
  • Offering Guidance: Claims adjusters often work closely with policyholders to gather necessary information and expedite the process.
  • Providing Clear Explanations: If a claim is denied, insurers typically explain the reason and outline any steps you can take to appeal the decision.

🛠️How to Improve Your Claims Experience

To ensure a smoother claims process, consider these tips:

  • Understand Your Policy: Know what is and isn’t covered so you’re prepared in case of a loss.
  • Keep Detailed Records: Document your belongings, keep receipts, and take photos of damage when filing a claim. Create a home inventory and keep it up to date.
  • Report Claims Promptly: Notify your insurer as soon as possible to start the process without delays.
  • Ask Questions: If you’re unsure about any part of the process, don’t hesitate to ask your agent or adjuster for clarification.

While no one likes to think about filing a claim, it’s comforting to know that insurance companies are there to help when you need them. Generally, providers are committed to fair and efficient claims handling. By understanding your policy and following best practices, you can navigate the claims process with confidence. If you have questions or need assistance, contact us—we’re here to help.

Learn about our Personal Insurance Policies

Personal Insurance
Personal Insurance Get A Quote

Every insurance company has its unique offerings, making it challenging to compare options effectively. That’s where we shine.

Learn about our Business Insurance Policies

Business Insurance
Business Insurance Get A Quote

Every insurance company has its unique offerings, making it challenging to compare options effectively. That’s where we shine.

Read our Claims Blog Posts

Home Inventory Made Simple The 30-Minute Method That Helps Claims Go Faster

Home Inventory Made Simple | The 30-Minute Method That Helps Claims Go Faster

A home inventory can speed up claims and reduce stress after a loss. Learn a simple 30-minute method for documenting your belongings quickly and effectively using your smartphone and cloud storage.
Read more
Man writing next to computer

Why Timely Notice Matters Under Claims-Made Liability Policies

Claims‑made liability policies require more than just having coverage in place. Timely notice of claims or potential claims is critical to preserve coverage and avoid unexpected gaps. This article explains how claims‑made policies work, how to identify if your policy is claims‑made, and practical steps businesses can take to stay protected.
Read more
Steering wheelSteering wheel

What Should You Do After a Car Accident to Help Your Insurance Claim?

A car accident can be stressful and overwhelming, especially in the moments that follow. This checklist outlines practical steps drivers can take after an accident to protect themselves, document key details, and help keep the insurance claims process on track
Read more
Murphy Insurance Team

27 Reasons to Work with Murphy Insurance Agency

For more than 88 years, Murphy Insurance Agency has been a trusted partner for families, individuals, and businesses across Massachusetts. As a family-owned and independent agency, we prioritize relationships over transactions, offering guidance and support tailored to your needs. With access to more than 25 top-rated carriers, we deliver personalized solutions, competitive options, and peace of mind. Discover 27 reasons why thousands have chosen Murphy Insurance to protect what matters most.
Read more
Check marks

Insurance companies are quick to deny claims | Insurance Myths

While it’s true that not every claim gets approved, the idea that insurers are eager to reject claims isn’t accurate. As a rule, insurance providers aim to resolve claims fairly and help policyholders recover after unexpected events. Let’s explore why this myth doesn’t hold up and what you can do to ensure a smooth claims process.
Read more
Understanding the Insurance Claim Process

Understanding the Insurance Claims Payment Process

In the aftermath of a disaster, understanding your insurance payment process is crucial for prompt recovery. Your insurer may issue multiple checks for temporary and permanent repairs, as well as replacements for damaged belongings, ensuring swift restoration to normalcy for both you and your insurance provider.
Read more
Starting a Business? Know the Risk Factors that go into Pricing Your Business Coverage 1200x628

Starting a Business? Know the Risk Factors that Go into Pricing Your Business Coverage

Successful startups require vision, passion, and appropriate business insurance coverage. While launching a new venture can incur expenses, cutting corners on insurance is not advisable because of its critical role in safeguarding business interests.
Read more
2022 Atlantic Hurricane Season Forecast to be ‘Above-Normal’

2022 Atlantic Hurricane Season Forecast to be ‘Above-Normal’

The 2022 Atlantic Hurricane Season is expected to be "above-normal," with 19 named storms, 9 hurricanes, and 4 major hurricanes. Home and business owners are advised to review their insurance policies, especially for flood coverage, and prepare by securing properties and creating emergency plans.
Read more
Top 10 Small Business Insurance Claims

Top 10 Small Business Insurance Claims

An analysis by The Hartford reveals that four out of 10 small businesses may face property or general liability claims within the next decade, with burglary and theft being the most common. However, the most expensive claim for small businesses involves reputational harm, encompassing issues like libel, slander, and privacy violations.
Read more
5 Tips for Solid Auto Insurance Coverage

5 Tips for Solid Auto Insurance Coverage

While car insurance typically covers vehicle damage, the most significant financial risk lies in injuring others without adequate Bodily Injury to Others coverage. Since accidents and their severity are unpredictable, ensuring sufficient coverage is crucial to safeguard against potential liabilities arising from injuries.
Read more
Settling Insurance Claims After a Disaster

Settling Insurance Claims After a Disaster

After a disaster, settling insurance claims can be daunting, but taking quick, informed steps can make all the difference. From contacting your agent to documenting damage and making temporary repairs, this guide outlines everything you need to know to get started and avoid costly pitfalls.
Read more
Dog Bites Accounted for More than 1/3 of All Homeowner Liability Payouts Last Year

Dog Bites Accounted for More than 1/3 of All Homeowner Liability Payouts Last Year

In 2015, dog bites and related injuries comprised over a third of all liability claim payouts in homeowners insurance. Despite a 7.2 percent decrease in nationwide dog bite claims, the average cost per claim surged by 16 percent.
Read more
Managing Insurance Costs...Understanding Deductibles, Frequency and Severity

Managing Insurance Costs…Understanding Deductibles, Frequency and Severity

Effectively managing insurance costs extends beyond coverage limits, options, and premiums; it includes evaluating the deductibles you're comfortable paying out of pocket.
Read more
Person on Computer

MA Dept of Industrial Accidents Requiring Electronic Filing of All First Reports of Injury by Jan 1, 2014

Starting January 1, 2014, the Massachusetts DIA requires all Form 101 First Reports of Injury (FRI) to be submitted electronically—paper copies will no longer be accepted. Employers can submit forms via secure file transfer or through the DIA website with an authorized online account. While this change affects submissions to the DIA, the process for notifying Murphy Insurance or your insurance company remains the same. To avoid delays, businesses should apply for a DIA Online Account as soon as possible.
Read more
Keep Your Home in Tip-Top Condition

Keep Your Home in Tip-Top Condition

In recent years, homeowners have grappled with soaring insurance costs and challenges in obtaining coverage, especially those with multiple claims. Yet, by implementing preventive measures, homeowners can mitigate future risks, making insurance more accessible and affordable.
Read more
Get Your Coverage Updated Well Before a Storm

Insurance Claim Tips For After The Storm

After Hurricane Sandy passes, it'll be crucial to assess the damage. To streamline the claims process for property or vehicle damage caused by the storm, consider implementing these helpful tips.
Read more
Get Your Coverage Updated Well Before a Storm

Remembering Irene…Lessons Learned

This time last year, the Northeast endured the aftermath of Hurricane Irene and an unexpected October snowstorm wreaking havoc in Massachusetts, resulting in extensive damage including downed trees and prolonged power outages.
Read more
PreviousNext