All car insurance is the same | Insurance Myths

May 16, 2025|Auto Insurance Myths|auto insurance, car insurance, personal insurance

Not true. Car insurance is not one size fits all. Policies can differ significantly in coverage, cost, and the level of protection they provide. What you are covered for depends on the type of policy you choose, the insurer, and your state’s specific requirements. While it may be tempting to focus only on price, that approach can leave gaps in your coverage. Understanding your options helps you choose a policy that truly fits your needs and provides the right level of protection..

Cars
Click here to submit an inquiry to Murphy Insurance or call us at 800 222 8711

🚙 What Most Policies Include

Typical components of car insurance may include:

  • Liability Coverage – Covers damage or injury you cause to others
  • Collision Coverage – Pays for damage to your vehicle after an accident
  • Comprehensive Coverage – Covers non-collision events like theft or storms
  • Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist – Protects you if the other driver has little or no insurance
  • Medical Payments or PIP – Helps cover medical bills for you and your passengers

While these are common, the amount of coverage, deductibles, and policy features can vary widely.

Key Differences to Consider

  • Coverage Limits – Higher limits offer more protection in serious accidents
  • Deductibles – What you pay before insurance kicks in affects your premium
  • Optional Add-ons – Extras like roadside assistance or accident forgiveness aren’t standard
  • Service & Claims Support – Insurer responsiveness and support matter when it counts

✅ How to Choose the Right Policy for You

Any insurance provider can lower your premium by reducing your coverage. However, this means you’re taking on more risk. Choosing the right car insurance policy isn’t about finding the cheapest option; it’s about finding the best value. Since car insurance policies aren’t all the same, here are a few tips to make sure you’re getting the protection you need:

  • Compare coverage, not just price: A cheaper premium may mean less protection.
  • Review your deductibles and limits: Make sure they match your financial situation and risk tolerance.
  • Ask about optional coverage: You may be able to add important protections for a modest cost.
  • Talk to a local agent: They can help you understand the fine print and make informed choices.

📞 We’re Here to Help

Navigating car insurance options can feel overwhelming, but you don’t have to do it alone. Our team is here to help you compare policies, identify savings opportunities, and find the coverage that’s right for you. Contact us today to get started.

Learn about our Personal Insurance Policies

Personal Insurance
Personal Insurance Get A Quote

Every insurance company has its unique offerings, making it challenging to compare options effectively. That’s where we shine.

Read our Insurance Myths

Checklist

You only need to update your insurance if you make a major life change | Insurance Myths

While major life events are an obvious reason to review your coverage, regularly updating your insurance ensures it continues to meet your needs—even if your life seems steady. Your lifestyle and possessions evolve over time, often in ways that may not feel monumental but can still impact your insurance needs.
Read more
Smiling woman

You only need life insurance if you’re older | Insurance Myths

Life insurance can be valuable at any age. Whether you’re in your twenties, thirties, or beyond, having a life insurance policy can offer a range of benefits tailored to your life stage and goals. Here’s why starting early can make a big difference.
Read more
Employee Lawsuits and EPLI Protection

Umbrella Insurance isn’t important for small businesses | Insurance Myths

Many small business owners believe umbrella insurance is only necessary for large corporations with complex risks—but that’s simply not true. The reality is, even small businesses can face lawsuits that exceed standard policy limits, and the financial consequences can be devastating. Umbrella insurance offers an affordable way to protect your business from the unexpected.
Read more
Person pushing wheel chair

My Health Insurance will cover my long-term care needs | Insurance Myths

While health insurance is excellent for covering medical treatments, surgeries, and hospital stays, it falls short when it comes to long-term care. Custodial care, often needed in nursing homes or through in-home care services, isn’t included in standard health insurance policies. This gap can leave you unprepared if you require extended assistance due to aging, illness, or disability.
Read more
Person using a walking stick

My employer provides me with Disability Insurance—I don’t need my own | Insurance Myths

Employer disability insurance is a valuable perk, but many plans only replace a portion of your income and coverage is tied directly to your job. If you leave your position, are laid off, or your employer decides to reduce benefits, your disability insurance typically doesn’t follow you, which could leave you without protection. Purchasing your own disability policy can better protect you.
Read more
Signing papers

Once I have insurance, I don’t need to review it | Insurance Myths

This myth could leave you underinsured or paying for coverage that no longer fits your needs. Regularly reviewing your insurance is essential to ensure your policies remain aligned with your current life circumstances. Here’s why.
Read more
Money

Insurance is too expensive for me | Insurance Myths

Insurance costs can feel overwhelming when managing a tight budget, but skipping coverage can result in much higher expenses from accidents, disasters, or losses. Various types of insurance—auto, home, life, and business—help protect your financial stability in unexpected situations. By understanding the risks of being uninsured and adjusting coverage to fit your needs, you can safeguard yourself without facing overwhelming costs later.
Read more
Globe

Insurance coverage is the same no matter where you live | Insurance Myths

Where you live plays a significant role in determining your insurance rates, coverage options, and even the types of policies available to you. Understanding these variations is key to ensuring you have the protection you need. Here’s why location matters in insurance.
Read more
Check marks

Insurance companies are quick to deny claims | Insurance Myths

While it’s true that not every claim gets approved, the idea that insurers are eager to reject claims isn’t accurate. As a rule, insurance providers aim to resolve claims fairly and help policyholders recover after unexpected events. Let’s explore why this myth doesn’t hold up and what you can do to ensure a smooth claims process.
Read more
Elderly couple

I only need life insurance if I have dependents | Insurance Myths

While providing for children, a spouse, or other loved ones is a common reason to buy life insurance, it’s far from the only benefit. In fact, locking in a policy early means you secure affordable rates before any future changes—whether that’s starting a family or facing unexpected health issues. Even if you don’t have dependents down the road, life insurance can still offer valuable benefits. In short, life insurance is a smart financial tool for anyone, no matter their family situation. Here’s why.
Read more
Family

My employer provides life insurance, so I don’t need my own policy to protect my family | Insurance Myths

Many people assume that the life insurance offered through their employer is all they need—but that’s not always the case. While it’s a great starting point, employer-provided coverage often falls short of what your family might actually need. Plus, if you leave your job or your company changes its benefits, that coverage may no longer be available. Learn more about why having your own individual life insurance policy is a smart way to ensure more stable, long-term protection.
Read more
Aoartment

I don’t need renter’s insurance because my landlord’s policy covers my stuff | Insurance Myths

While your landlord’s policy likely covers the building structure and common areas, it doesn’t extend to your possessions or your personal liability. Renter’s insurance safeguards your belongings and provides liability protection. For a relatively low cost, renter’s insurance offers invaluable peace of mind and financial security. Here's why you should purchase it if you rent your home.
Read more
House with keys

Home insurance will cover every type of personal liability | Insurance Myths

While home insurance does include liability coverage, no policy covers everything. Understanding the limits and exclusions of your policy is essential to making informed decisions and being prepared for the unexpected. For more extensive or specific liabilities, additional policies like umbrella insurance may be necessary. Here’s what you need to know to make informed decisions.
Read more
Money

Insurance should be bought and used for every accident or disaster | Insurance Myths

While it’s tempting to lean on your insurance policy whenever something goes wrong, doing so can have unintended consequences. Insurance is meant to protect you from significant financial setbacks—such as a major accident, storm damage, or liability claim—not to serve as a go-to solution for every minor mishap. What many people don’t realize is that every time you file a claim, it’s recorded in your insurance history. Insurers use this information to evaluate your risk profile, which can impact your premiums as well as overall insurability.
Read more
Whiteboard

Insurance premiums are set in stone and can’t be changed | Insurance Myths

While it might seem obvious that premiums can fluctuate, many people are surprised to learn just how many different factors influence those changes. Yes, your claims history matters—but so do larger economic forces, industry trends, and environmental shifts. Let’s take a closer look at what can influence your premiums and how you might be able to lower them.
Read more
Arrows

A higher deductible will always lower my costs | Insurance Myths

When looking at increasing your deductible to lower costs is typically true to some extent, the decision is more nuanced. Opting for a higher deductible can save you money on premiums, but it also means you’ll face higher out-of-pocket costs if you need to file a claim. Let’s break down the factors to consider before deciding on your deductible.
Read more
Handshake

Insurance policies are just a way for companies to make money | Insurance Myths

While insurance providers are businesses that aim to make a profit, their primary purpose is to offer protection and financial security to individuals and families. Insurance is fundamentally designed to shield you from significant financial loss. By pooling resources from many policyholders, insurance companies can help individuals recover from unexpected events such as accidents, natural disasters, or other unforeseen circumstances.
Read more
Writing on paper

Insurance policies are always complicated and hard to understand | Insurance Myths

While policies are indeed detailed legal contracts, they don’t have to be intimidating. Insurance agents can help you understand your coverage and make informed decisions. Let’s debunk this myth and show how policies can be approachable with the right resources.
Read more
Car front

I have Health Insurance, so I don’t need medical coverage for my Car Insurance | Insurance Myths

Many health insurance plans come with high deductibles, copays, or limited coverage for certain types of injuries. In the event of a car accident, these gaps could leave you facing significant out-of-pocket expenses. Medical coverage on your car insurance policy helps bridge these gaps, ensuring that accident-related medical costs are taken care of.
Read more
Insurance papers

I don’t need insurance if I don’t own a home or car | Insurance Myths

Think you don’t need insurance because you don’t own a home or car? Think again—renter’s, non-owner car, life, and disability insurance all provide critical protection for your belongings, income, and future, no matter your living or driving situation. Whether you’re renting, living with others, or occasionally borrowing a car, having the right coverage ensures you're financially protected when the unexpected happens.
Read more
Papers

All insurance providers are the same—it doesn’t matter who you buy your insurance from | Insurance Myths

Not all insurance providers are the same, and believing otherwise can lead to costly mistakes. Choosing an insurance provider isn’t like picking a product off the shelf—it’s about selecting a partner to help you protect your assets and plan for the unexpected. Here's a closer look at the three main types of insurance providers and how they differ.
Read more

I’ve never had a car accident, so I don’t need automobile insurance | Insurance Myths

No matter how cautious and skilled a driver you are, accidents can happen. Road conditions, weather, other drivers, or even wildlife can create situations beyond your control. You might never cause an accident, but what about the driver who runs a red light or the unexpected hailstorm? Automobile insurance provides a safety net for the unforeseen.
Read more
Car crash

If I’m not at fault in an accident, my insurance won’t be affected | Insurance Myths

Even if you’re not at fault, your insurance might still be affected. Insurance companies assess risk based on your overall claims history, not just who was at fault. Here are some factors that could lead to higher premiums.
Read more
Flooded home

Home insurance covers all types of damage | Insurance Myths

While standard home insurance provides a valuable safety net, no home insurance policy covers everything. Understanding the limits of your policy is crucial to managing your risks and avoiding misunderstandings about what's covered when a claim situation occurs. Every homeowner’s needs are unique. Reviewing your policy regularly and consulting with a Murphy Insurance agent can help ensure you have the coverage you need.
Read more
Umbrella

Umbrella Insurance isn’t important for everyone | Insurance Myths

Lawsuits can happen to anyone, and the financial impact can be overwhelming if damages exceed your standard insurance limits. Whether it’s a slip-and-fall on your property or an auto accident, legal and medical expenses can add up quickly. If your home, auto, or watercraft policy doesn’t cover the full cost, you’re responsible for the rest. Umbrella insurance provides an extra layer of protection, ensuring you’re not left paying out of pocket for unexpected claims.
Read more
Car on road

Insurance is required to drive a car, so if someone hits me, there is coverage | Insurance Myths

If you're in a car accident but aren't responsible, you can't always rely on the other driver's insurance because not everyone carries adequate coverage. Some people drive with no insurance at all, and others may only purchase the minimum required liability coverage, which often isn’t enough to cover all damages in a serious accident. So, it's important to have your own protection in case of an uninsured or underinsured driver.
Read more
Foot cast

If I become disabled, Social Security will take care of me | Insurance Myths

While Social Security Disability Insurance can provide some financial assistance, it’s often not enough to cover all your needs and maintain your current lifestyle. Relying solely on SSDI might not offer the level of financial security you might anticipate. Even if your employer provides disability protection, having your own disability insurance is worth considering.
Read more
Family

Only the “Breadwinner” in the home needs Life Insurance | Insurance Myths

It's a misconception that only a "breadwinner" in the household needs life insurance. The contributions of a "nonworking" spouse/partner are just as valuable to the family and household, even if they don’t come with a paycheck. Make sure that every contributor to the household has life insurance to protect the family. The Hidden Value of a “Non-Working” Spouse A spouse or partner who doesn’t earn a traditional income often wears many hats: childcare provider, housekeeper, chef, chauffeur, tutor, and even household accountant. Imagine trying to replace all those roles at once—it would add up to more than a full-time job. The cost of outsourcing these responsibilities can be significant, putting a financial strain on a family already dealing with the emotional toll of losing a loved one.
Read more
Couch

Renters Insurance isn’t necessary if your stuff isn’t worth much | Insurance Myths

It’s easy to underestimate the value of your personal property. But think about it: if you were to lose everything in a fire or other disaster, how much would it cost to replace your clothes, furniture, electronics, and everyday essentials? The replacement value of these items adds up quickly, even if you don’t own high-ticket items. Learn how renters insurance ensures you won’t have to start from scratch.
Read more
Person driving

I only drive my car occasionally, so I don’t need higher limits | Insurance Myths

Even if you drive infrequently, the risk of causing an accident when you do drive is no different from that of a daily driver. If you’re involved in an accident, your liability for any injuries or property damage you cause doesn’t decrease just because you drive occasionally, so maintain solid insurance protection limits is crucial.
Read more
Person in wheel chair

If another driver causes an accident and I’m hurt, their Auto Insurance pays for my injuries | Insurance Myths

While the law requires drivers to carry insurance, not everyone complies. Some people drive without insurance, while others carry only the bare minimum. That minimum coverage might not come close to covering your medical bills, lost wages, or other damages if you’re seriously injured. Thankfully, you don’t have to rely solely on other drivers’ insurance. Your auto policy can include coverage to protect you in these scenarios.
Read more
Flood

Flood Insurance is only essential if you live in a high-risk area | Insurance Myths

Many people mistakenly believe they don’t need flood insurance because they don’t live in a designated high-risk flood zone. However, flooding can happen anywhere, whether it’s caused by heavy rains, rapid snowmelt, hurricanes, or even broken water mains. It doesn’t matter if you live in a low-risk or moderate-risk area—the financial impact of flooding can be devastating without proper coverage.
Read more
PreviousNext